|
Delaware
|
0-22239
|
33-0711569
|
|||
|
(State
or other jurisdiction of incorporation)
|
(Commission
File Number)
|
(IRS
Employer Identification No.)
|
|
18872
MacArthur Boulevard, Suite 200, Irvine, California
|
92612-1400
|
||
|
(Address
of principal executive offices)
|
(Zip
Code)
|
|
¨
|
Written
communications pursuant to Rule 425 under the Securities Act (17 CFR
230.425)
|
|
¨
|
Soliciting
material pursuant to Rule 14a-12 under the Exchange Act (17 CFR
240.14a-12)
|
|
¨
|
Pre-commencement
communications pursuant to Rule 14d-2(b) under the Exchange Act (17 CFR
240.14d-2(b))
|
|
¨
|
Pre-commencement
communications pursuant to Rule 13e-4(c) under the Exchange Act (17 CFR
240.13e-4(c))
|
|
(d)
|
Exhibits
|
|
99.1
|
Press
release dated February 25, 2010
|
|
99.2
|
Transcript
of Conference Call by Autobytel Inc., dated February 25, 2010 and Call
Presentation Slides
|
|
Exhibit
Number
|
Description______________________________________________________________________________
|
|
99.1
|
Press
Release, dated February 25, 2010
|
|
99.2
|
Transcript
of Conference Call by Autobytel Inc., dated February 25, 2010 and Call
Presentation Slides
|
|
AUTOBYTEL
INC.
|
||||||
|
UNAUDITED
CONSOLIDATED BALANCE SHEETS
|
||||||
|
(Amounts
in thousands, except share and per-share data)
|
||||||
|
December
31,
|
December
31,
|
|||||
|
2009
|
2008
|
|
||||
|
Assets
|
||||||
|
Current
assets:
|
||||||
|
Cash
and cash equivalents
|
$ 25,097
|
$ 27,393
|
||||
|
Accounts
receivable, net of allowances for bad debts and customer credits of $1,107
and $1,277, at December 31, 2009 and December 31, 2008,
respectively
|
8,573
|
10,047
|
||||
|
Prepaid
expenses and other current assets
|
594
|
1,378
|
||||
|
Total
current assets
|
34,264
|
38,818
|
||||
|
Property
and equipment, net
|
1,003
|
2,421
|
||||
|
Investment
and other assets
|
123
|
763
|
||||
|
Total
assets
|
$ 35,390
|
$ 42,002
|
||||
|
Liabilities
and Stockholders' Equity
|
||||||
|
Current
liabilities:
|
||||||
|
Accounts
payable
|
$ 2,539
|
$ 3,579
|
||||
|
Accrued
expenses and other current liabilities
|
4,028
|
6,432
|
||||
|
Deferred
revenues
|
603
|
1,835
|
||||
|
Total
current liabilities
|
7,170
|
11,846
|
||||
|
Non-current
liabilities
|
79
|
181
|
||||
|
Total
liabilities
|
7,249
|
12,027
|
||||
|
Commitements
and contingencies
|
||||||
|
Stockholders'
equity:
|
||||||
|
Preferred
stock, $0.001 par value; 11,445,187 shares authorized; none
outstanding
|
-
|
-
|
||||
|
Common
stock, $0.001 par value; 200,000,000 shares authorized;
|
|
|
||||
|
45,168,706
and 45,219,679 shares issued and outstanding, as of December 31, 2009 and
December 31, 2008, respectively
|
45
|
45
|
||||
|
Additional
paid-in capital
|
301,831
|
300,720
|
||||
|
Accumulated
other comprehensive income
|
-
|
568
|
||||
|
Accumulated
deficit
|
(273,735)
|
(271,358)
|
||||
|
Total
stockholders' equity
|
28,141
|
29,975
|
||||
|
Total
liabilities and stockholders' equity
|
$ 35,390
|
$ 42,002
|
||||
|
AUTOBYTEL
INC.
|
||||||||||
|
UNAUDITED
CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS AND COMPREHENSIVE
LOSS
|
||||||||||
|
(Amounts
in thousands, except per-share data)
|
||||||||||
|
Three
Months Ended
|
Twelve
Months Ended
|
|||||||||
|
December
31,
|
December
31,
|
|||||||||
|
2009
|
2008
|
2009
|
2008
|
|||||||
|
Revenues:
|
||||||||||
|
Lead
fees
|
$ 10,807
|
$ 12,259
|
$ 46,236
|
$ 63,169
|
||||||
|
Advertising
|
1,408
|
1,888
|
6,508
|
7,794
|
||||||
|
Other
revenues
|
35
|
59
|
174
|
196
|
||||||
|
Total
net revenues
|
12,250
|
14,206
|
52,918
|
71,159
|
||||||
|
Cost
of revenues (excludes depreciation of $229 and $616 for the three months
ended December 31, 2009 and 2008, respectively, and $1,088 and $1,844 for
the twelve months ended December 31, 2009 and 2008,
respectively)
|
7,463
|
14,238
|
33,986
|
51,384
|
||||||
|
Gross
profit
|
4,787
|
(32)
|
18,932
|
19,775
|
||||||
|
Operating
expenses
|
||||||||||
|
Sales
and marketing
|
2,596
|
3,527
|
10,179
|
17,997
|
||||||
|
Technology
support
|
1,200
|
4,079
|
5,244
|
15,391
|
||||||
|
General
and administrative
|
2,113
|
7,607
|
11,591
|
22,635
|
||||||
|
Patent
litigation settlement
|
(44)
|
42
|
(2,892)
|
(2,667)
|
||||||
|
Goodwill
impairment
|
-
|
-
|
-
|
52,074
|
||||||
|
Total
operating expenses
|
5,865
|
15,255
|
24,122
|
105,430
|
||||||
|
Operating
loss
|
(1,078)
|
(15,287)
|
(5,190)
|
(85,655)
|
||||||
|
Interest
and other income
|
114
|
229
|
1,028
|
1,346
|
||||||
|
Provision
(benefit) for income taxes
|
21
|
-
|
(606)
|
-
|
||||||
|
Loss
from continuing operations
|
(985)
|
(15,058)
|
(3,556)
|
(84,309)
|
||||||
|
Discontinued
operations, net
|
15
|
4
|
1,179
|
4,393
|
||||||
|
Net
loss
|
$ (970)
|
$
(15,054)
|
$ (2,377)
|
$ (79,916)
|
||||||
|
Basic
and diluted loss per common share:
|
||||||||||
|
Loss
from continuing operations
|
$ (0.02)
|
$ (0.34)
|
$ (0.08)
|
$ (1.91)
|
||||||
|
Discontinued
operations, net
|
-
|
-
|
$ 0.03
|
0.10
|
||||||
|
Basic
and diluted loss per common share
|
$ (0.02)
|
$ (0.34)
|
$ (0.05)
|
$ (1.81)
|
||||||
|
Comprehensive
loss
|
||||||||||
|
Net
loss
|
$ (970)
|
$
(15,054)
|
$ (2,377)
|
$ (79,916)
|
||||||
|
Unrealized
loss from investment
|
-
|
(112)
|
-
|
(118)
|
||||||
|
Comprehensive
loss
|
$ (970)
|
$ (15,166)
|
$ (2,377)
|
$
(80,034)
|
||||||
| AUTOBYTEL INC. | ||||||||||
|
Reconciliations of Net Loss, Loss from Continuing Operations, Gross
Profit
Margin, and Total Operating Expenses
|
||||||||||
| (Amounts in thousands, except per-share data) | ||||||||||
| Three Months Ended | Twelve Months Ended | |||||||||
|
December 31,
2008
|
Earnings
Per
Share
|
December 31,
2008
|
Earnings Per Share | |||||||
| Net Loss | $ (15,054) | $ (0.34) | $ (79,916) | $ (1.81) | ||||||
| Severance-related costs | 5,102 | 0.12 | 6,864 | 0.16 | ||||||
| Impairment charges | 5,500 | 0.12 | 57,574 | 1.31 | ||||||
| Net Loss, excluding severance | ||||||||||
| and impairment charges | $ (4,452) | $ (0.10) | $ (15,478) | $ (0.35) | ||||||
| Three Months Ended | Twelve Months Ended | |||||||||
|
December 31,
2008
|
Earnings
Per
Share
|
December
31,
2008
|
Earnings Per Share | |||||||
| Loss from continuing operations | $ (15,058) | $ (0.34) | $ (84,309) | $ (1.91) | ||||||
| Severance-related costs | 5,102 | 0.12 | 6,864 | 0.16 | ||||||
| Impairment charges | 5,500 | 0.12 | 57,574 | 1.31 | ||||||
| Loss from continuing operations, excluding | ||||||||||
| severance and impairment charges | $ (4,456) | $ (0.10) | $ (19,871) | $ (0.45) | ||||||
| Three Months Ended | ||||||||||
|
December
31,
2008
|
Margin % | |||||||||
| Gross profit | $ (32) | -0.2% | ||||||||
| Severance-related costs | 300 | 2.1% | ||||||||
| Impairment charges | 4,300 | 30.3% | ||||||||
| Gross profit, excluding | ||||||||||
| severance and impairment charges | $ 4,568 | 32.2% | ||||||||
| Three Months Ended | ||||||||||
|
December 31,
2008
|
% of
Revenues
|
|||||||||
| Total net revenues | $ 14,206 | 100% | ||||||||
| Operating expenses | 15,255 | 107% | ||||||||
| Severance-related costs | (4,802) | -34% | ||||||||
| Impairment charges | (1,200) | -8% | ||||||||
| Gross profit, excluding | ||||||||||
| severance and impairment charges | $ 9,253 | 65% | ||||||||
| AUTOBYTEL INC. | ||||||||||||||
| UNAUDITED CONSOLIDATED STATEMENTS OF OPERATIONS AND COMPREHENSIVE LOSS | ||||||||||||||
| (Amounts in thousands, except per-share data) | ||||||||||||||
| The following tables set forth selected statements of operations and comprehensive loss data, presenting previously reported amounts and amounts as corrected for the three and six month periods ended June 30, 2009 and the three and nine month periods ended September 30, 2009. | ||||||||||||||
| Three Months Ended | Six Months Ended | |||||||||||||
| June 30, 2009 | June 30, 2009 | |||||||||||||
|
As
Previously
Reported
|
Correction of
Error
|
As Corrected
For
Error
|
As
Previously
Reported
|
Correction of
Error
|
As
Corrected
For Error
|
|||||||||
| Operating loss | $ (2,199) | $ - | $ (2,199) | $ (2,702) | $ - | $ (2,702) | ||||||||
| Interest and other income | 675 | - | 675 | 821 | - | 821 | ||||||||
| (Benefit) Provision for income taxes | - | (495) | (495) | - | (495) | (495) | ||||||||
| Loss from continuing operations | (1,524) | 495 | (1,029) | (1,881) | 495 | (1,386) | ||||||||
| Discontinued operations, net | 1,273 | (495) | 778 | 1,273 | (495) | 778 | ||||||||
| Net loss | $ (251) | $ - | $ (251) | $ (608) | $ - | $ (608) | ||||||||
| Basic and diluted loss per common share: | ||||||||||||||
| Loss from continuing operations | $ (0.03) | $ 0.01 | $ (0.02) | $ (0.04) | $ 0.01 | $ (0.03) | ||||||||
| Discontinued operations, net | 0.03 | (0.01) | 0.02 | 0.03 | (0.01) | 0.02 | ||||||||
| Basic and diluted loss per common share | $ (0.01) | $ - | $ (0.01) | $ (0.01) | $ - | $ (0.01) | ||||||||
| Three Months Ended | Nine Months Ended | |||||||||||||
| September 30, 2009 | September 30, 2009 | |||||||||||||
|
As Previously
Reported
|
Correction of
Error
|
As Corrected
For
Error
|
As Previously
Reported
|
Correction of
Error
|
As Corrected
For
Error
|
|||||||||
| Operating loss | $ (1,411) | $ - | $ (1,411) | $ (4,113) | $ - | $ (4,113) | ||||||||
| Interest and other income | 94 | - | 94 | 915 | - | 915 | ||||||||
| (Benefit) Provision for income taxes | 124 | (256) | (132) | 124 | (751) | (627) | ||||||||
| Loss from continuing operations | (1,441) | 256 | (1,185) | (3,322) | 751 | (2,571) | ||||||||
| Discontinued operations, net | 642 | (256) | 386 | 1,915 | (751) | 1,164 | ||||||||
| Net loss | $ (799) | $ - | $ (799) | $ (1,407) | $ - | $ (1,407) | ||||||||
| Basic and diluted loss per common share: | ||||||||||||||
| Loss from continuing operations | $ (0.03) | $ - | $ (0.03) | $ (0.07) | $ 0.01 | $ (0.06) | ||||||||
| Discontinued operations, net | 0.01 | - | 0.01 | 0.04 | (0.01) | 0.03 | ||||||||
| Basic and diluted loss per common share | $ (0.02) | $ - | $ (0.02) | $ (0.03) | $ - | $ (0.03) | ||||||||
|
Operator:
|
Hello,
my name is (Dawn) and I will be your conference operator
today. At this time I would like to welcome everyone to the
Autobytel Announces 2009 Year-end Financial Results conference
call.
|
|
|
All
lines have been placed on mute to prevent any background
noise. After the speaker's remarks there will be a
question-and-answer session. If you would like to ask a
question during this time simply press star then the number one on your
telephone keypad.
|
|
|
If
you would like to withdraw your question, press the pound the
key. I will now turn the call over to Roger Pondel, Investor
Relations. Please go
ahead.
|
|
Roger
Pondel:
|
Thank
you (Dawn). Good afternoon everyone and welcome to Autobytel’s
2009 fourth quarter and year-end conference call. With me on
the line are Jeff Coats, President and Chief Executive Officer, and Curtis
DeWalt, Chief Financial Officer.
|
|
|
Before
we begin, I'd like to remind you that during today's call, including the
Q&A session, any projections and forward-looking statements made
regarding future events and the future financial performance of the
Company are covered by the Safe Harbor Statement contained in today's
press release and in the Company's filings with SEC. Please
note that actual events or results may differ materially from these
forward statements. Specifically refer to the Form 10-Q for
quarter ended September 30, 2009, the Form 10-K for the year ended
December 31 of 2008 and the Form 10-K for the year ended December 31,
2009, which is expected to be filed next week. These filings address
factors and risks that could cause results to differ materially from those
forward-looking statements.
|
|
|
I
will now turn the call over to
Jeff.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Thank
you, Roger. Good afternoon everyone. For Autobytel
2009 was a year characterized by reinvestment and refocus. We
better aligned our business for current industry dynamics and built a
solid foundation from which we believe we can achieve our goals of top
line growth and profitability. Against what turned out to be one of the
worse automotive markets in almost a half century, we shifted our focus
back to our core lead generation busi+
ness
and identified ways to provide increasing value to automakers and auto
dealers to help them market and sell new and used
vehicles.
|
|
|
I
am pleased that on February 10th, we received a letter from The NASDAQ
Stock Market notifying us that we have regained compliance with the
previously reported minimum $1.00 closing bid deficiency and that the
matter is now closed. We consider this an important milestone in
Autobytel's turnaround story.
|
|
|
As
expected, while revenues remain under pressure in the short-term, gross
margins improved by approximately 400 basis points in fourth quarter of
2009 on top of 200 basis point gains in the third
quarter.
|
|
|
By
working more efficiently we reduced operating costs by an additional 4.8
percent on a sequential basis. Thus we achieved significant
gross margin improvement, substantially streamlined our cost structure,
see signs of improvement in our dealer network, and in the last two months
of the year generated positive cash
flow.
|
|
|
While
our industry struggled through 2009, our foresight to maintain a strong
cash position, invest strategically when warranted and reduce spending
where ROI hurdles were not being met helped us end the year with $25.1
million in cash. We also remain debt
free.
|
|
|
With
the general economy now showing early signs of recovery and the auto
industry is starting to generate some positive momentum, our strong
balance sheet will allow us take advantage of opportunities as they
present themselves especially as our auto industry customers begin to
benefit from an improving sales environment. By way of example, as shown
on slide three, in December 2009, U.S. new, light vehicle sales improved
by 15 percent on a year-over-year basis, and in January of this year sales
growth was six percent year-over-year. While we obviously are not out of
the woods, there is definitely some evidence to suggest that the worst may
be behind us.
|
|
Curtis
DeWalt:
|
Thank
you, Jeff. Before I begin please note my comparisons to prior
year Q4 results excluded the impact of $5.1 million of severance costs and
$5.5 million of non cash impairment charges recognized in that quarter. We
believe this provides a more representative depiction of our
year-over-year performance. You can find a detail review of our
GAAP results for 2008 Q4 and full year in the earnings release we
distributed earlier this afternoon as well as the slides we have posted to
our website that were mentioned at the beginning of this
call.
|
|
|
As
shown on slide four, total revenues for Q4 were $12.2 million, down
approximately nine percent from $13.4 million for 2009 Q3 related in part
to the normal seasonal trends as well as Cash for Clunkers program which
pulled demand forward into Q3 and then resulted in lower fourth quarter
dealer inventory; and down 14 percent year-over-year. The
reduction in 2008 fourth quarter relates to general economic and
automotive sector weaknesses, which also tracks to overall 2009 auto sales
being down approximately 21 percent. As you know, the automotive sector
struggled considerably throughout 2009 as dealers went out of business and
many of those that remained reduced or stopped spending marketing
dollars. As a result our network of dealers producing revenue
declined throughout the year. However, we did begin to see signs for
improvement late in the fourth
quarter.
|
|
|
At
the end of 2009 fourth quarter we were serving 2,064 new car franchises,
up from 2,021 in Q3 of 2009, but down from 2,651 in the prior year
period. Our used car dealer franchises totaled 924 at the end
of 2009 Q4, roughly flat with 923 at the end of Q3 2009, but down from
1,106 in Q4 in 2008.
|
|
|
Finance
lead revenue was off 13 percent from Q3 of this year and declined 39
percent from the prior year Q4, due principally to a reduction in the
number of participating dealers and a decrease in revenue per
participating dealer, as obtaining financing for subprime consumers has
been difficult by any historical standards. We don’t expect to see a
significant change in these dynamics in the near term, however anecdotal
evidence from automotive news suggest that banks are just beginning to
loosen credit guidelines making it a bit easier for subprime buyers to
purchase vehicles again.
|
|
|
We
delivered approximately 76,000 finance leads in 2009 Q4, 12 percent lower
than in Q3 2009 and 25 percent lower than last year's
Q4. Financed dealer franchises totaled 221 at the end of 2009
Q4 compared with 186 at the end of 2009 Q3 and up from 214 in 2008
Q4.
|
|
|
Q4
advertising revenue declined 13 percent from 2009 Q3 and declined 25
percent from last year's Q4. The decline in sequential
advertising revenue is due to seasonality and a high number of page views
experienced in Q3 of 2009, related to the Cash for Clunkers program, while
the year-over-year decrease is related to the lower number of page views
principally due to the elimination of certain third party traffic
providers. In 2009 we undertook efforts to improve the quality
of the traffic by eliminating underperforming traffic sources. While this
resulted in fewer page views but the performance of our advertising has
improved. We believe we should be able to leverage this higher performance
to secure OEMs and other auto related categories who are currently not
advertising on our site and to eventually obtain higher advertising rates
across the board in recognition of a more competitive marketing
product.
|
|
|
There
were approximately 32 million total web page views across the internet
properties in 2009 Q4, down 33 percent from 48 million in Q3 2009 and 37
million in the year ago period. The sequential decrease is again related
to a significant number of page views related to Cash for Clunkers in Q3
as well as the elimination of certain third party traffic sources. The
year-over-year decline related to a greater focus on lead generation from
our own websites versus driving increased page views as well as the
elimination of certain third party
providers.
|
|
|
In
the current quarter we delivered approximately 664,000 auto leads compared
with 675,000 in the prior quarter and 652,000 in last year's
Q4. The sequential decline in lead delivery was the result of a
pull forward in customer demand generated by Cash for Clunkers program and
seasonal fall-off. On a year-over-year basis the increase is due to a
greater number of leads delivered directly to OEMs and through our
wholesale network, partially offset by lower lead delivery to individual
dealers.
|
|
|
Gross
margins also benefited from increased number of internally generated leads
and was 39.1 percent in 2009 Q4 up from 35.5 in Q3 of this year and 32.2
in Q4 of last year, excluding severance costs and good will impairment,
which we took in that quarter. In Q4 2009 we also benefited from the
realization of previous incurred advertising
revenue.
|
|
|
Slide
six clearly illustrates our substantial cost structure improvements over
the past year. Operating expenses declined by another 4.8
percent to $5.9 million from $6.2 million from the preceding third
quarter, and by approximately 36 percent from the prior year period. Last
year's fourth quarter total operating expenses were $9.2 million excluding
severance charges and goodwill
impairment.
|
|
|
The
net loss for 2009 Q4 was $970 thousand or two cents per share, which
included approximately $15,000 of income from discontinued operations
primarily related to final release of funds from the escrow account that
we established pursuant to the sale of our AVV business in January 2008.
This represents a considerable improvement from the net loss of $4.5
million or ten cents per share excluding severance cost and related
impairment in Q4 2008.
|
|
|
Before
moving to the balance sheet I’d like to take a moment and give you a brief
overview of the full year's results as seen on slide
seven. Revenue for 2009 totaled $52.9 million compared with
$71.2 million for 2008. The net loss was $2.4 million or five cents per
share for 2009, including $1.2 million of income for discontinued
operations.
|
|
|
While
there was no impact on our net losses on our balance sheet or our cash
flows for these periods during the second and third quarters of
2009.
|
|
|
The
company’s income taxes were misstated with the provision for income taxes
from continuing operations higher than actually reported and offsetting a
like amount reported in the provision for income taxes from discontinued
operations. The corrections to these quarterly financials are summarized
in the tables to our press release and will be reflected in our form 10-K
for the year-end of December 31
st
2009, which we expect to file next
week.
|
|
|
With
that I’ll now turn the call back to
Jeff.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Thank
you Curt. We made steady and important progress throughout
2009, not only strengthening our brand and reputation in the marketplace,
but beginning to strategically invest in our future. I believe that we
ended the year in a significantly stronger position than we entered 2009
and that we moved into 2010 poised to return to top line growth and
profitability.
|
|
Autobytel
has been delivering value to the auto industry for 15 years. In that time
we have witnessed many changes, some good, some not as
good. However, one thing has remained constant over that period
of time, the internet’s ability to provide the most cost-effective, ROI
driven performance-based marketing opportunities available to the auto
industry to sell more new and used vehicles. Seventy percent of the 200
auto dealers that we surveyed last month for Autobytel’s 15
th
anniversary automotive internet dealership survey said they planned to
increase their spending on internet marketing in 2010. Only 4 percent said
they would decrease spending while the remainder said they would keep
spending on a par with 2009. All dealers surveyed said that
their internet strategies had helped them through these challenging times.
Automotive news recently reported from the National Automobile Dealers
Association convention in Orlando, Florida that many dealers are forsaking
other forms of advertising in favor of the internet. One dealer noted that
he has reduced his advertising cost per car to $125 from $300 by focusing
on the internet. Given what we know about the industry’s need
to protect its bottom line, these results and stories come as no
surprise.
|
|
|
For
Autobytel these dynamics provide us with a good backdrop against which to
build on our greatest strengths, our OEM and dealer relationships and the
products and services we provide them, as well as our suite of popular
websites which provide valuable robust content to automotive consumers.
Autobytel is once again ahead of the curve in providing our industry and
consumers with the tools they need especially in a recovering
economy.
|
|
|
In
addition to incorporating tools and content from other top notch
automotive websites we are regaining our own editorial voice and starting
to give consumers a best of the web perspective. Time and again
in market, car buyers have demonstrated the importance of the internet to
their vehicle purchase decisions. In fact, according to a
recent J. D. Power news release, 76 percent of new vehicle buyers now use
the internet in their shopping process – a historical
high.
|
|
|
We're
continuing to integrate this and other data, content, tools, photos and
graphics and are working toward a relaunch of autobytel.com with a new
user interface and voice in the third quarter of this
year. During 2010, we anticipate that all of our sites will
have undergone substantial improvements paving the way for increased lead
generation of our websites and optimized advertising
performance. We intend to provide the most robust automotive
experience anywhere on the web.
|
|
|
Recently
we rolled out an industry first lead product, icontrol by Autobytel, to
better meet the needs of our large dealer customers. icontrol
puts dealers in charge of their leads by allowing them to configure those
leads by lead source, model, territory or combination of all
three. Never before seen in the auto industry icontrol
addresses something dealers have long been asking for – a way to match
their lead mix to their inventory and local market conditions. This
powerful platform is highly flexible, easy to use and controllable from
either the dealership or dealer group level. As anticipated
initial dealer, response to icontrol has been overwhelmingly
positive.
|
|
|
We
have come a very long way in a relatively short amount of time since
refocusing our operations and concentrating on those activities that we
believe will result in both short and long-term value for our
customers. We continue to work to help OEMs and dealers market
and sell vehicles and to provide innovative internet marketing solutions
keeping Autobytel a “must- have” tool in their efforts to generate and
close consumer automotive leads in the most cost effective way
possible.
|
|
|
We
entered 2010 reenergized and feeling optimistic about the future, with the
most recent J. D. Power forecast indicating an improvement in new vehicle
sales of $11.7 million, up 12 ½ percent from 2009, and with an increase of
up to $15 million in 2012. Over the coming year we will
continue to develop and innovate programs to provide value to automobile
automakers and dealers to help them sell more vehicles. We will enhance
our websites with the industry’s best content to provide increasing value
to consumers who are increasingly using the internet during the car buying
process. We will continue our efforts to run our operations as
efficiently as possible to drive sustained profitability and grow
shareholder value. As a result of our efforts, we believe we
will be able to show continued improvement in our gross margins and
achieve our goals of top line growth and profitability in
2010.
|
|
|
We
are convinced we are doing the right things to strengthen our position in
the marketplace while using our financial flexibility to its utmost
benefit. Even in this economy, and perhaps because of it,
strategic opportunities abound. As I mentioned in prior calls
the auto industry and its diverse segments are ripe for change and
consolidation, and we are well positioned to benefit from this, and intend
to.
|
|
Operator:
|
If
you would like to ask a question please press star and then the number one
on your telephone keypad. Again, if you would like to ask a
question please press star and the number one on your telephone
keypad. We'll pause for just a moment. Again, if you
have a question press star one at this time. Your first
question comes from Brian Horey from Aurelian
Management.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
Thanks
for taking my question. Perhaps on some improved progress this
quarter just a few questions. You noted I think you said some
signs of improvement in the dealer network. Can you add a
little bit of color to what you're seeing in terms of attracting
additional dealers to the network?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Well
it’s always a mixed bag. As part of introducing some new products,
icontrol in particular, we are seeing increased dealer
interest. And you know a large part of what keeps dealers in
our network or coming into our network is our ability to send them high
quality, good close rate leads. The fact that we're now
focusing or refocusing our efforts on generating more leads internally off
of our own sites, which again generally are among the best quality, is a
big plus for us. It's a big selling point for dealers as
well.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
Do
you have any have any sense as to how much upside there is in the dealer
count over the next two quarters.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Well
it's kind of difficult to prognosticate on that with the dealer count
around 2,000 out of a universe of something around 15 or 16,000. We
believe there is some upside here.
|
|
|
Just
a few years ago we were more than double where we are now. So I
think as a result again of refocusing our efforts on our lead generation
and our lead business, we will see an improvement in the dealer
count.
|
|
|
Obviously,
improvement in the dealer count is a top priority for us since it is a
prime driver of our revenue.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
Right. The
OpEx was down a little bit more this quarter which is nice to
see. Can you talk about where you found the incremental
efficiencies in terms of OpEx?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Curt,
you want to talk about that?
|
|
Curtis
DeWalt:
|
Yes. Again
it’s a number of things. We reduced expenses as contracts came
up for renewal, I’ll pick insurance premiums, at the beginning of the year
we had leases, we have professional fees; there is just a whole host of
things, literally down to the paper clips, that everybody has a different
mindset around here in the way we spend money and when we count everything
and at the end of the month, I mean there is just a lot more
accountability and appreciation for what the expenses are. Its amazing how
all that adds up. The headcount and all has pretty much
stabilized. We've been watching the
overtime. Obviously in the case of the sales being off
somewhat, commissions are down somewhat, but overall I think it's just
really there is no one area you could point to; it's really a concerted
effort across the full spectrum of
expenses.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
OK.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
I
will tell you that you won't – you will not see any additional large
reductions in operating expenses.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
OK.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
We're
…
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
Well,
that’s kind of what you said last quarter and you did better than that so
I'm just wondering if maybe there is some more
upside?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
No,
we're always going to try to do a little bit better than that, but we're
also kind of turning the corner moving into a new year, and we're
reinvesting in the business a little bit and bringing in a few additional
people to drive things forward, so…
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
OK.
|
|
Curt
DeWalt:
|
That
could make the distinction between expenses and investments so while some
of the numbers may go back up they're hopefully going to also be paying
for themselves.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
Right. I
think I heard you mention, I just wanted to confirm this, did you say that
since Q1 the number of internally generated leads has increased 9X did I
hear that?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Yes.
You did.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
OK. Which
has had obviously a great impact on your gross margin? What
kind of upside do you think there is from year-end gross margin and the
ability to drive more organic lead
volume?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Well
I don't think we will see an increase of 9 times during
2010. We will see additional pick up. Not really
sure quite yet where it will settle out. Part of that will be a
result of what's going on in the market for new
cars.
|
|
|
And
as I said in the remarks, there are some early signs of improvement but
until unemployment gets straightened out and auto financing is widely
available, there are still going to be issues. So I think we'll
see an increase but not that
dramatic.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
OK.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
And
in terms of gross margin, we are optimistic about some further material
improvements in gross margin.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
OK. And
then one last question in terms of the lead volume and the impact of car
sales and all that kind of stuff. I mean we all obviously all
understand the impact of Cash for Clunkers. But if I look at
the SAR data for the last few months, I mean there has been a pick up in
that and even if you kind of look at the last few years, it looks like
your kind of Q3 to Q4 new car lead revenue was down a little bit more this
year then prior years.
|
|
|
I
mean is there anything else going on besides the Cash for Clunkers
effect?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Not
really. I mean there is still a little bit of the malaise in
the marketplace this year because of what has happened or last year rather
in 2009. But the two big drivers really were a demand pulled
forward into the third quarter driven by Cash for Clunkers which then
resulted in a lack of inventory on dealership
lots.
|
|
|
Because
the 2009’s were pretty well sucked out of the system through Cash for
Clunkers because dealers had already pretty well managed down their
inventories during the course of the
year.
|
|
|
And
then the 2010 models were not delivered in nearly the volumes of past
years and were a little bit later. I mean remember factories
for certain manufacturers were closed entirely or production was cut
back.
|
|
|
So
it was really – there was a lack of inventory in the system. We
heard that over and over again. So dealers are not going to buy
leads if they don't have cars to
sell.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
Yes. Are
you getting a sense that kind of things are back to a more stable
inventory environment and selling environment as we're in the New Year
versus where we were in fourth
quarter?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
I
think things are getting back to normal. I was down in Orlando
ten days ago for the National Automobile Dealers Association and I can
tell you the difference between 2010 NADA and 2009 was pretty
dramatic.
|
|
|
Last
year was like a wake, and this year there were a lot of optimistic people,
so I think people are pushing forward. The attitudes look good,
and I think the OEMs are giving off better vibes this year than they were
last year.
|
|
Brian
Horey:
|
OK. Thanks
very much for your time and congrats on all the progress in the
quarter.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Thank
you. Thanks for your interest
Brian.
|
|
Operator:
|
Your
next question comes from the line of Richard Mansouri with Dellacamera
Capital.
|
|
Richard
Mansouri:
|
Yes. Thank
you. I want to talk about a topic that we've spoken about it
seems like many, many times, Jeff, as a matter of fact I'm looking at a
transcript from last year's conference call dated March 12th of 2009, and
one of the questions comes from and I focus on the cash and it says here I
said, "So I guess, I'm just trying to understand why the company, why the
board hasn’t authorized an open market share repurchase program for at
least some portion of the cash that the company
has."
|
|
|
Now
this was a year ago, and you're response according to this transcript is
"Richard, as you know from prior conversations that you and I have had
that the Board is in fact considering a lot of different strategic
alternatives. We are in fact discussing the possibility of some
sort of a stock buy back. There have been no decisions made at
this point in time."
|
|
|
Then
there is a lot of other text. Then you end that paragraph by
saying "that doesn’t mean that we are saying we are not going to do a
stock buy back. It just means that we're currently considering that among
other options."
|
|
|
So
I'm hearing some positive progress on the operational front which you guys
should be commended for this one year. So I guess my question
is what is it that you're currently considering that would be better than
utilization of cash to buy back stock because we're in a close to
historically low interest rate environment and we've been hearing the same
thing about the board or the company considering this usage for probably
more than a year. Can you just comment on that
please?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Richard
as always such a pleasure to talk to
you.
|
|
Richard
Mansouri:
|
And
it's so nice that you can say that with a straight face, but I don't know
if you're saying it with a straight face or not but thank
you.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
I
can say it with a straight face. You're right those were my
remarks last year. I think in the context I can tell you at
that point and time the board was considering a lot of different
options. If we look back to March of last year the stock was
close to an all time low. We made the decision obviously, not
to implement a stock an open market stock buy-back last
year.
|
|
|
Candidly,
because of current market conditions, the market conditions at that time,
our market conditions, not the stock market but the automotive market
conditions, where two of our biggest customers were on the brink of filing
bankruptcy and decided it was better to conserve our cash. We
currently believe that there are other better uses for our cash than to
implement a stock buy-back. There are numerous strategic
opportunities in the marketplace.
|
|
|
I
have repeatedly said that we are in the midst of looking at those
opportunities. The best that I can say right now with regards
to that is stay tuned. If you're only in the stock hoping that
we're going to do a stock buy-back, I'm not going to say anything today
that's going to make you happy. And that's about as candid and
honest as I can be.
|
|
Richard
Mansouri:
|
And
it's appreciated your candor. I don't know anyone who's in the stock for
just a buy-back. I'm just trying to understand the company’s
thinking. And again, we're not saying that you've done anything
imprudent with the cash, its right to be prudent. It's just a
question that has been on our mind some time because you have to admit the
company has been sitting on a fair amount of cash in the context of the
overall market cap of this company for some time. Would you not
agree?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Yes,
I would. I would agree. I mean your question is not surprising
nor imprudent at all. I completely agree. Again, I would say
given the circumstances and the period of time, there are some incredibly
interesting opportunities. So I guess I would say just be
patient a little longer.
|
|
Richard
Mansouri:
|
OK.
It’s appreciated. Thanks, once
again.
|
|
Operator:
|
Your
next question comes from the line of William Martin with Raging
Capital.
|
|
William
Martin:
|
All
right. Good afternoon gentlemen. How are
you?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Hi
Bill. You?
|
|
William
Martin:
|
Just
curious. Without the Cash for Clunkers which pulled ahead a lot of
business, do you think you would have been so cash flow positive for the
full quarter?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
For
the full quarter well it would be reasonable to assume
that. There was a big demand-pull forward and it's kind of
interesting because a lot of people believed even in the July time frame
that Cash for Clunkers was only going to pull forward
demand. It was not really going to increase overall demand and
that is what ended up happening perhaps in large part because there was
not enough inventory in the system to support higher sales. It
really did suck a lot of inventory out of the
system.
|
|
William
Martin:
|
Right. Looking
at the substantial increase in organic leads -- first off congratulations
– it’s tremendous progress. Just curious what are you doing there and how
sustainable is it?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
You
know a portion of it is just basic blocking and tackling. Some
of it is just fixing things with the websites that needed to be fixed,
doing some upgrades and better focus on search marketing. Most
of this has been generated thus far with search marketing, which is of
course is paid. We've begun doing, excuse me, doing some search
optimization but haven't been able to do as much of that while we're in
the process of basically fixing and upgrading the
websites.
|
|
|
We've
come a pretty long way in terms of fixing the things that needed to be
fixed, improving and optimizing the sites and beginning to integrate the
content and technology and reviews, photos and everything that we've
gotten out of the various transactions that we've done. So we
believe that this year we will be able to see a nice improvement in our
search optimization activities. Sustainable,
yes.
|
|
William
Martin:
|
Great. Are
you starting to see the automakers spend money again on
advertising?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
They
are starting to spend money on advertising particularly with new launches
that are coming out this year. There's a lot of interesting stuff going on
so we are beginning to see it, yes.
|
|
William
Martin:
|
And
given the consolidation in the dealer space what can you just talk about
your initiatives to better target some of the larger auto dealer networks
and also some of the auto OEMs?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Sure. We
already do business with a significant number of the OEMs, probably a
significant majority of the OEMs in one form or
another. Different OEMs have different types of corporate lead
programs so we participate with each one on their respective
bases. We have been increasing our penetration in the
OEMs. We recently have been part of some new programs with some
new OEMs that we haven't done business with for a
while.
|
|
|
We
are working on some additional, we are in discussions with some additional
OEMs either directly or indirectly for additional
business. With regards to the dealer groups, we do business
with many if not most of the large dealer groups, but there're interesting
animals. Just because you do business with a large dealer group does not
mean you have all of the dealers in that dealer group signed up on your
program. What you kind of get from most of them, not all, there
are always exceptions, are a bit of a hunting license. You get a blessing
from corporate to then go out and market to the individual dealerships
within the dealer group to have them sign up for your
program.
|
|
|
Some
provide you a little bit more help in that than others, but it's not
dramatically different from just going out and signing up
dealers. We do think that some of the new products that we're
working on like icontrol that we recently announced should help, and
preliminarily seem to be helping us pretty
significantly. Because icontrol gives the dealer groups at the
corporate office much more control and visibility over what they're doing
so they can allocate all the way down to the dealership level all the way
down to the make and model and turn them up and turn them down from a
territory standpoint so there's a lot of functionality, which is very
helpful for the large leader groups. So we do think this will
help us from a penetration standpoint within the dealership groups that
we're already in and for signing up new
ones.
|
|
|
It's
been very well received thus far.
|
|
William
Martin:
|
Great,
and Jeff I'm just curious how is your thinking evolved about strategic
opportunities in the sector given the pretty dramatic fundamental
improvement in the business?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
The
opportunities are seemingly still
there.
|
|
William
Martin:
|
You're
just in a better position?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Yes. Well
you know our stock is stronger. Our results are obviously doing
better. We are regaining credibility in the marketplace, and as
you well know being in a transactions mode a buyer has to have credibility
with a seller regardless of the form of the
transactions.
|
|
|
So
I think I'm cautiously optimistic about what will occur during
2010.
|
|
William
Martin:
|
Should
I read that last part of that statement in saying that you're more likely
to be a buyer of assets than a seller or were you just using an example
there?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Well
my general counsel is sitting here shaking his head. But I
really would like to answer that. So I'm going to answer
that. We are more likely to be a
buyer.
|
|
William
Martin:
|
Got
it. OK. Well, Jeff, if I could weigh in with my two
cents on the stock buy-back topic real quick. I would say as a
large shareholder I would note that while perhaps large is a percentage of
the company's total market cap, your cash that is, in the grand scheme of
things it's not a large amount of
money.
|
|
|
And
I really believe the optionality of that cash is extremely valuable so I
like having you guys sitting tight with it right now. So thank
you for all your hard work. It is greatly
appreciated.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Thank
you. We appreciate your support and
interest.
|
|
Operator:
|
Again
if you would like to ask a question please press star one on your
telephone keypad. You have a question from the line of Robert
Setrakian with Helios.
|
|
Robert
Setrakian:
|
Hi
guys, congratulations. Really on the great quarter and great
year in difficult environment. You have made a lot of
progress.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Thank
you Robert.
|
|
Robert
Setrakian:
|
I'm
going to ask a question I think for the first time in ten quarters I'm
going to break my record and not make any comments or ask any questions
about the stock buy-back or insider buying, but I'll focus on something
else this time.
|
|
|
In
the press release it says, "We generated positive cash flow for the month
of November and December." Is this a trend that you expect to
continue going forward?
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Since
– well let me equivocate as much as possible on my answer. You
know we are not planning to give guidance. So I think what you
can look at are the other comments that I made in the remarks related to
returning the top line growth and profitability in
2010.
|
|
|
We
do reasonably expect to believe to be – that we will be profitable in
2010.
|
|
Robert
Setrakian:
|
Yes. I
mean if you do the math and if you extrapolate on the month of November
and December and you do the math on the comments that you’ve made one
should reasonably expect the trend to continue, which is
excellent.
|
|
|
And
this is all based obviously on a certain SAR level in industry if we have
a little bit of an improvement there then we could really do
well. That’s the way I read it, and hopefully I'm reading it
correctly.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
It's
probably a reasonable assessment. I mean obviously a big part
of the improvement has been related to a big improvement in cost of
revenue.
|
|
Robert
Setrakian:
|
Yes.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
And
we continue to believe that we have ways to continue to improve our cost
of revenue. And that will eventually
…
|
|
Robert
Setrakian:
|
Great.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
…
have a big impact and as our sales recover during the course of the year.
Things should naturally flow from
there.
|
|
Robert
Setrakian:
|
Great. Congratulations. Thank
you again.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Thank
you, Robert.
|
|
Operator:
|
There
are no further questions in queue. I would now like to turn the
call over to Jeff Coats for closing
remarks.
|
|
Jeff
Coats:
|
Well,
I guess I'm pretty well burned out on additional remarks. You
know we appreciate everybody's support. As I said to Richard,
please stay tuned. We do believe 2010 is going to be a very
dynamic year for us this year.
|
|
|
It
certainly looks like the general economy is beginning to
recover. The automotive economy seems to be showing signs of
growth, and we do believe we will benefit from that in a myriad of
ways. So, thank you again, and we look forward to speaking to
you all soon.
|
|
|
Thank
you, Operator.
|
|
Operator:
|
You're
welcome sir. This concludes today's conference
call. Thank you for participating. You may now
disconnect.
|
|
|
END
|
|
|
Q1
2010
|
Q2
2010
|
Q3
2010
|
Q4
2010
|
|
|
•
Done
:
Soft
re-launch of
Autobytel.com (configurator, compare tool, updated home page, rebuilt new & used vehicle research, better user experience, Edmunds and Kelley Blue Book reviews)
•
Additional
Edmunds &
Kelley Blue Book content integration (advice, car comparisons, and other articles) |
•
Blog -
Daily
automotive news and features
•
Kelley Blue
Book
video integration
•
Email rebate
alerts
for customer retention
•
Enhanced
Video
|
•
Formal
re-launch
of Autobytel.com with new user interface
•
Consumer
ratings, reviews, and article comments
•
Custom
RSS
feeds for articles & news |
•
Reliability
ratings
•
Dealer
ratings
•
Mobile
tools
|
|
Ongoing
|
•
Consumer
research (usability, focus groups and surveys)
•
Multivariate
website testing
•
Differentiation
of primary properties vs. each other and competition;
incremental
improvements to secondary sites
•
SEO
optimization
•
Increase SEM
on all sites
•
More in-depth
car reviews and other content by Autobytel staff (developing our own
voice)
•
Syndication
partnerships
|
|||